Yesterday at BarCamp Ohio I sat listening to a conversation among people who were trying to balance the need to be involved in social media outreach with the need to run their businesses. Their frustration was based on the fear that as they finally embraced a social network or site, the masses would move some place new. For a company focused on running a business instead of playing in the social media sphere, it's a valid concern.

As someone who remembers the massive rush to (and from) sites like Orkut and Spock over the last few years, I know most social media applications have a limited life span. The concepts will remain, but new companies will pop up with better ways of doing things, just as Google pushed Alta Vista and Northern Light aside in the search world. So while I adore Twitter and LinkedIn today, I also realize something better may come along down the road.

The Bleeding Edge of Social Media

cliffwalk.gifWhile part of my job is testing and playing with these new applications and networks to find out what has practical application for small business, that isn't the job of most small business owners. Which brings me to my point.

It is simply not practical for most small businesses to be on the bleeding edge of social media adoption.

They call it the "bleeding edge" for a reason, you know.

In fact, that bastion of collective knowledge known as Wikipedia defines the bleeding edge like this:

...technology that is so new (and thus, presumably, not perfected) that the user is required to risk reductions in stability and productivity in order to use it."

Now, let's consider the last part of the definition again, shall we?

...risk reductions in stability and productivity in order to use it."

The majority of small businesses I've dealt with do not have the ability to risk reductions in stability or productivity. They're generally all working their tails off to build their companies and meet payroll.

Not an Excuse to Ignore Social Media

mapwalk.gifNow, in no way should this post be taken as me telling small businesses not to work on incorporating a social media plan into their marketing. Social media is fast becoming one of the absolute most important channels for small businesses to consider. Never before have companies had such insight into the thoughts of their customers.

That said, companies seem to fall into two general categories when it comes to social media. They either run full speed trying to stay ahead of the curve or they shrink back in fear, afraid to take a chance on any site. Unfortunately, both groups end up dealing with a different type of trouble. They either waste time that could better be spent running their business, or they miss out on the opportunities to grow their business.

The true challenge for small businesses when it comes to social media isn't deciding whether or not to get involved, it's in remembering to balance the needs of your business with the need to market your company. It's why the person in charge of your social media initiative needs to have a knack for both exploration and valuation.

The Value is in the Leading Edge, Not the Bleeding Edge

rainbowwalk.gifThe nice thing about the bleeding edge is if you take just a few steps back, you can enjoy the view without the bleeding. That should be the goal of most small businesses...to stand near enough to the edge to see the big picture, but to stay far enough from the edge to avoid getting hurt.

For the greatest majority of businesses, there's nothing wrong with hanging back and waiting to see if a new social media option will "take." Playing in well established spaces like YouTube, Flickr and Facebook is entirely different than investing the time in Plurk, Utterz, Seesmic and any other funny named social media site to pop up.

Established social media sites also have established user bases. They've reached a point of saturation high enough to make them worth using. While the hot new social media network might be getting a lot of press, it's important to remember the press comes far before the users, at least in terms of having enough users to create a base worth marketing non-tech products to. Even something as talked about as Twitter still has only around 1.2 million registered accounts.

There's no shame in taking your time to find out if a social network is going to continue to grow before getting involved. You still want to get in early, you just don't need to be the first person there. In fact, one of the best ways to decide if a social media site is right for you is if your customers are there. It's easy enough to scan the conversation at sites like Twitter, Flickr, YouTube, Facebook and other sites to find out what's being talked about.

If you see conversation taking place related to your products or services, it might be a good place to get involved. If not, your time is probably better spent elsewhere.


August 12, 2008





Jennifer Laycock is the Editor of Search Engine Guide, the Social Media Faculty Chair for MarketMotive and offers small business social media strategy & consulting. Jennifer enjoys the challenge of finding unique and creative ways to connect with consumers without spending a fortune in marketing dollars. Though she now prefers to work with small businesses, Jennifer’s clients have included companies like Verizon, American Greetings and Highlights for Children.





Comments(6)

Whether the bleeding edge or leading edge, it's important for SoMe directors or strategists to make sure clients/employers understand that SoMe is ever changing and needs to be constantly evaluated. You have to stay flexible in your strategy, experiment, shift focus. This isn't just a sound SoMe strategy but for many marketing strategies. Opportunistic marketing is important. The world moves way too fast to plan a strategy a year in advance. Some things can be laid out, leaving room for shifts in target audience behavior, company mission, technology, even social movements.

Jennifer,
Great article. Small businesses are really trying to decide how/when/where to embrace this.

You really summed it up well and I think put some anxiety to rest for those who just don't have the resources to spend on a full blown social media campaign.

I do think small niche businesses must pick one or 2 tho and get started. I am working for some great people who are still trying to decide if blogging is helpful!

I'm sending them the link to this article for inspiration! I think they can realize that you don't have to do it all, but you can benefit from using some of the tools that will reach out to their target market.

Social media is such a low cost production that company's can't risk not taking advantage of its potential. All you have to do is hire an army of part-time interns, give them guidance as to the overall goals, teach them some tactics, and deploy. If you are a small business doing 3 million in revenues and under, you can really benefit from an extra 1000 people to your site per day. The risk factor comes when you get in to large corporations that, much of the time don't understand how to use social media, and allocate huge budgets to something that may not work well. Two places I would suggest as resources to getting help.... www.readtheanswer.com/index.php?RTA=web2
http://www.JohnAssaraf.com/hia/challenge.htm?s=hiac2008

Jenifer, as usual you make some great points. Personally, I think Social Media is 90% hype and 10% value. Jill Whalen recently said something along the lines of SM isn't new it is just what we called community in the past or "building community". I think the best approach for small business is to figure out what parts of Social Media fit with their site and do it themselves! For instance YouTube could be used to collect topical vids from users posted to YouTube and displayed on the site. There is a growing list that says promotion on SM sites has little payback in $. When Google writes off the mySpace spend as likely not material that says a ton about the payback. How many bizs can take that time away from the biz and see no return. No, it either has to be fulfilling on a personal level or be paying back with $'s.

The real value from SM is in branding and visibility. IMO, for small biz this is usually not a luxury they can afford or need to have as a priority. The money and time is often better used in other places. Don't do it because you feel you have to, to be cool. Do it because it works for you in achieving a goal. In short have a plan... and work the plan.

Just about the only form a SM that works for the small business owner is the blog. These folks don't often have the time to blog, but we tell them to make time.Outside of that it gets very unrealistic for the small business owner to find for SM.

For them SM is social mingling at a business mixer bar.

I think the local business owner will eventually adopt a social strategy, its just going to happen. There's no better to interact with the customers which these business owners are looking for.

Jippidy.com - Video Yellow Pages

Comments closed after 30 days to combat spam.


Search Engine Guide > Jennifer Laycock > Small Business Can Step Back from the Bleeding Edge of Social Media