Search Engine Guide
Home
Search
Engines
Knowledge
Base
Vendor
Directory
Newsletters
About
Search The Internet: 


Rank Write Logo
Article provided with permission by
Rank Write Roundtable.
© 2000 Rank Write Roundtable.


Directory and Search Engine Submissions Are Totally Different
By Jill Whalen - November 30, 2000 (From the Rank Write Roundtable Newsletter)

~~~High Search Engine Rankings~~~

From: Scott Rubel

Do the engines read the text we put UNDER the picture? I am referring to the text that often is limited to just a title of the picture that you see flash or linger on the screen in the table where the picture is about to load.

A more important question, perhaps:

In your 11/23 article "Submitting to Directories", you say "To be safe, a good rule of thumb is to use your company name or the official name of your Web site."

Yet, in [your article] "All About Title Tags", you say "Many site owners mistakenly believe they should put their company names in this tag. This is only a good idea if you are a well-known company...." In this article you talk about word repetition in the title tag and putting more keywords in. Does this seeming contradiction mean that if you optimize your site for the directories, it will not do as well in automatic search engines? If this is the case, we have to decide which will get us found more often.

Scott Rubel
Fine Paper Co.
InviteSite.com
111 E. Union St.
Pasadena, CA 91103


~~~Jill's Response~~~

Scott,

Two good questions! I believe in your first question, you are referring to the image "Alt Tag." Some search engines do read Alt Tags, and some don't. Alt Tags were designed to enable people who surfed with their images turned off (less and less people these days) to be able to "see" what a particular graphic showed. Webmasters are supposed to describe the graphic using the Alt Tag. It is my understanding that Alt Tags are also read out loud by text readers for the blind so that they will not miss out on important navigational buttons and the like. Because some search engines do read this tag, and do give some weight to the words placed in them, it can sometimes help your rankings to use important keyword phrases in this tag where appropriate.

As to your second question, regarding Titles...there is actually no contradiction going on at all. What is confusing you is the word "Title" being used to describe two completely different animals. Directory submissions and Search Engine submissions are two totally different processes. This may also confuse others, so let's take a moment to review the differences.

Directories such as Yahoo!, DMOZ and LookSmart, make you submit all the information about your site, including its URL, Title and brief description, using their special submit form. From the information you provide on this form, their human editors make the final decision on how your site gets listed in their Directory. On the other hand, Search Engines such as AltaVista, Google, and HotBot have you submit *only* your Web site address (URL). Using the URL only, their automatic robotic spiders go to work "reading" your site and gobbling up the pertinent information that it naturally supplies.

In your first example from my "Submitting to Directories" article, when I talked about the "Title," I was referring to the information you actually enter on the Directory's submittal form in the "Title" field (or "Name of Web site" field). Remember that the tags and HTML code on your actual Web site is fairly irrelevant to Directory editors. It's the information you submit on their form that they use to decide how to add your site to their database. As my article states, you absolutely MUST use your company or Web site name for most Directory submission forms, or there's a good chance you won't get listed. It would be a lot easier to get high rankings if you *could* use keywords in the Directory Title field, but unfortunately, in most instances, you can't. The reason is that Directories want some sort of consistency in their listings, and we can't really blame them for that.

In your second example, regarding my "All About Title Tags" article, the word "Title" refers ONLY to the information that you put in your tag in your *actual* Web page HTML code. This has nothing to do with what you submit to a Directory, but has everything to do with how your site will be ranked by the spidering Search Engines. In this tag it's important NOT to waste space with company names that no one has ever heard of, and instead use your most important and descriptive keyword phrases.

So you see, Directory Titles and the Title in your HTML code of your page DO NOT need to match, and in most cases, should NOT match. Two different animals, yet both equally important for high rankings. Hope this clears up any confusion!

- Jill


~~~Send Us Your Questions~~~

If you have questions about online copywriting or search engine optimization (or both!), just zip us an email to questions@rankwrite.com. We've had some folks ask if their question was "too basic" to be printed - and you don't have to worry about that! There are no "stupid" search engine optimization or copywriting questions, so ask away!